SEIAA Defers Karapur Complaints Pending Before High Court, Seeks Clarification on EIA Applicability

Panaji, June 20: The Goa State Environment Impact Assessment Authority (GSEIAA) has deferred consideration of several complaints relating to development and construction activities in Survey Nos. 148/0 and 176/1 of Carapur village, Bicholim, citing that the issues are already under adjudication before the Bombay High Court at Goa. According to the Authority’s decision, multiple representations and complaints had been received regarding the large-scale development activities being undertaken in the area. However, GSEIAA observed that the concerns raised substantially overlap with issues presently being examined by the High Court in PIL W.P. (F) No. 688/2025 filed by Pravinsingh Arjun Shedgaonkar and others. Invoking the legal principle of sub judice, the Authority decided that further consideration of those complaints which are directly connected to matters pending before the High Court would remain deferred to maintain judicial consistency and discipline. At the same time, the Authority separately examined representations submitted by local residents Shashikant Keshav Gaonkar, Sanjeevani Sarvesh Gaonkar, Gopi Bholo Talkar and Abhijit Prabhudesai. These complaints specifically raised questions regarding the applicability of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2006 to the ongoing development activities in Survey Nos. 148/0 and 176/1. During deliberations, GSEIAA noted that the project proponent is currently undertaking four construction projects within Survey No. 148/0: Astra (Plot No. A-134) Celeste (Plot No. B-135) Nova (Plot No. B-262) Orion (Plot No. B-442) The Authority has now sought clarifications from the project proponent regarding the total built-up area of the projects, the proximity between the various developments and other issues highlighted by the complainants. The clarification has been sought to determine whether the cumulative nature and scale of the projects attract the provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006, which mandates environmental scrutiny and clearances for certain categories of development projects. The development is being viewed as a significant step in the ongoing Carapur controversy, as environmental concerns raised by local residents have now formally come under the scrutiny of the state’s environmental regulatory authority. While the High Court will continue to examine broader issues related to the project, the GSEIAA’s decision to seek additional information on EIA applicability could potentially have important implications for the future course of the development.

  • Related Posts

    Congress Alleges NDZ Proposal is ‘Environmental Greenwashing’; Amit Patkar Questions Role of Section 39A

    The Goa Pradesh Congress Committee on Saturday accused the BJP government of using a proposed No Development Zone notification as a political exercise to conceal years of environmental destruction and questionable planning decisions in the state. Former GPCC President Amit Patkar questioned the role of Section 39A and alleged a lack of transparency in the NDZ proposal.

    EIE Welcomes Supreme Court Verdict on Pedestrian Rights, Demands Removal of Casino Encroachments

    Enough is Enough Goa welcomed the landmark Supreme Court judgment declaring the right to walk safely on demarcated footpaths as a Fundamental Right under Article 21 of the Constitution and called for immediate action against encroachments on public pedestrian spaces in Goa. The statement, issued by EIE core member Elvis Gomes, said the verdict serves as a major victory for public safety while exposing the failure of successive Goa governments to protect pedestrian rights from powerful commercial interests.

    You Missed

    Congress Alleges NDZ Proposal is ‘Environmental Greenwashing’; Amit Patkar Questions Role of Section 39A

    Congress Alleges NDZ Proposal is ‘Environmental Greenwashing’; Amit Patkar Questions Role of Section 39A

    EIE Welcomes Supreme Court Verdict on Pedestrian Rights, Demands Removal of Casino Encroachments

    EIE Welcomes Supreme Court Verdict on Pedestrian Rights, Demands Removal of Casino Encroachments

    SEIAA Defers Karapur Complaints Pending Before High Court, Seeks Clarification on EIA Applicability

    SEIAA Defers Karapur Complaints Pending Before High Court, Seeks Clarification on EIA Applicability

    गोंयकार जागा होईल ?

    गोंयकार जागा होईल ?

    योग दिन सक्ती अयोग्य

    योग दिन सक्ती अयोग्य

    पुरुष !

    पुरुष !